Archdiocese of Portland in Oregon
Archdiocesan Pastoral Council
MINUTES
April 22, 2006
The Griffin Center, Portland
Present: Archbishop John G. Vlazny, Fr. Dennis O’Donovan, and Members: Clint Bentz, Deacon Harold Burke-Sivers, Thom Faller, B.J. Finleybranch, Michelle Forster, Sr. Ruth Frank, Fr. Don Gutmann, Bruce Heldt, Eloisa Hernandez, Ray Houghton, F.J. Maloney, Eleanor Myers, Rick Nelson, Diane Peterson, Pat Ridenour, and Fr. Dick Rossman
Staff Present: Todd Cooper and Fr. Chuck Lienert
Not Present: Jesus Bojorges, Mother
Francine Cardew (E), Francisco Peña, & Deacon An Vu (E)
The twenty-first meeting of the Archdiocesan Pastoral Council (APC) was called to order at 10:05am by the council chair, F.J. Maloney. Eleanor Myers led the opening prayer.
The minutes from the February 4, 2006 meeting of the APC were approved with the following correction on page four, paragraph one: “Eight or nine” men participated in the Archbishop’s Annual Priesthood Discernment Retreat.
The meeting agenda was approved with the addition of the following item: Salem Area Prison Ministry.
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE REPORT
SALEM AREA PRISON MINISTRY
Eloisa Hernandez noted that Deacon Mendez also spends time doing ministry in the prisons in Salem.
A Catholic presence is what is needed and that does not have to come primarily
from a priest. It can come from a deacon or religious.
Unfortunately, prison/jail ministry is not a strength of the archdiocese.
At the city metro level, there is not much support for even a non-denominational ministerial presence.
The Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RILUPA) requires that state prisons reasonably accommodate prisoners’ religious needs.
If the APC gets involved in prison ministry as a pastoral priority, it should do so in a comprehensive way. For example, on the archdiocesan level, training could be provided for prison ministry volunteers. In this specific case, it seems that vicariate cooperation on the local level could tackle the issue successfully.
Deacon Harold sits on a board with the person who oversees the prisons. He will check to find out what the situation is regarding the Catholic chaplain position.
FJ will draft a letter and send it in response to Queen of Peace.
BANKRUPTCY UPDATE
We are looking for a number – an amount. Once the pot is determined, others will decide how to divvy it up. One challenging issue has been determining how to place a value on future claims. Another difficult issue is that there is a group of claims that are believed to be fraudulent.
The judge made a recent determination that if a case is seeking punitive
damages, it must be heard in Federal court, otherwise, it will be heard
in State court. In either case – settlement or no, it is costly.
Attorneys’ fees are extensive. The archdiocese already cut $1.3 million
and 25 jobs two years ago and now we are looking at another $1 million
in cuts. As much as we can cut programs, we will save jobs.
There will be a special session of the Presbyteral Council this Thursday
afternoon to seek the input of the priests on the needed cuts.
On a positive note, there has been movement from the insurance companies
and there is almost a settlement with four companies.
The goal in the proceedings is to
respect civil law and operate under our Church law as well. Protection
of assets is important and so borrowing is where we want to go.
There are currently 115-120 unresolved claims. 140+ claims have been settled. In one particular set of claims, the State of Oregon also feels the claims have no merit.
No plan will be approved that the archdiocese cannot afford. Any plan will require sacrifice. We will have to start operating as a smaller diocese. Healing, where possible, is still a priority. Protection of children is still a priority.
The Archdiocesan Loan & Investment Program (ALIP) fund is still operating within certain parameters.
What does the bankruptcy mean for the parish? Should I keep giving at the same level? We are all being sued. In all likelihood, parish assessments will go up. Catholic Appeal money will be safe.
While recovery of victims will be the priority, what help is planned for parishioners and others who have been victimized?
Is it true that some parishes would suffer more from a higher assessment? Yes, especially some smaller parishes, and the diocese is looking at how to address that issue.
ANNUAL VICARIATE MEETING OF PASTORAL COUNCILS (AVMPC)
Discussion of the bankruptcy at the
AVMPC should be constructive. Moving “beyond bankruptcy” should be
the focus. Regardless of finances, our relationship with God remains
intact and the work of the Church continues. Now is the time to refocus
our efforts in building God’s kingdom. The idea of best practices
sharing overlaps with this positive, “moving forward” approach. With
regard to the bankruptcy, the APC Vicariate Reps should not place themselves
in a position of trying to give answers to questions, but of listening
to parishes’ concerns about the bankruptcy and taking these back to the
council and the archbishop.
LUNCH 12pm to 1pm
PHYSICIAN ASSISTED SUICIDE
The initial and worthy response on the part of those opposed to assisted suicide was to work to improve end of life care. Vast strides have been made in the area of palliative care in Oregon in the last decade. Now, there is great end of life care throughout the state, especially at Providence. Opponents to assisted suicide are now taking a new approach to fighting the practice of assisted suicide.
With regard to the assisted suicide (death with dignity) law, what many Oregonians understand to be the law, with proper safeguards and accountability is not what the law actually requires. Assisted suicide is one of the few medical procedures where there is no malpractice – neither civil nor criminal, and much is not being reported. Even death certificates do not show when a death was an assisted suicide. Reporting of physician assisted suicide is not mandatory. This is not right.
Oregon leads the nation in elderly suicide. Why do we have assisted
suicide here? Many can picture the little old lady in agony at the end
of life. We say “I want to go out under my own terms.” We share
a mentality that “there are lots of fates worse than death.” Some
doctors reach a point where, since there is nothing else to do medically,
they want to give a lethal prescription. It becomes a technological
imperative.
Dr. Bentz provided handouts for the council
on Physician Assisted Suicide, including a position paper. There
are two opposing views that should be taken into account. The first
is the approach of treating the underlying issues when someone is suicidal.
The second is to treat by lethal prescription.
There is a difference between assisted suicide and euthanasia. In assisted suicide, the doctor writes the order of a lethal prescription and the patient administers it. In euthanasia, the doctor actually administers the lethal dose himself.
Catholic health care is doing great end of life care, but the physicians
are not opposing assisted suicide. I have come today to ask the archdiocese
to address this issue by increasing awareness, mobilizing the people, and
getting the priests to talk about it.
Physician assisted suicide is a horrible
practice – and it is happening in our diocese. My patients are dying.
What am I personally doing? I am trying to instill in my patients
the understanding that they are valuable as persons and they have dignity
as human beings. I am beginning to make house calls to impress upon
patients that they are important and that I hold them in high regard.
Physicians for Compassionate Care (PCC) is working to make its organization
a little more compassionate. We want to give physicians the tools
and skill sets they need to help patients, especially in end of life care.
Reverence is the best approach. That is my pledge to my own patients.
It took my own patient being killed before I was called to action.
I hope it is not soon a parishioner or family member.
Doctors are not trained in palliative
care in medical school. This needs to happen.
Q & A
Where do physicians stand? There seems to be a fairly casual attitude. We are the only state in the nation with this law. We have perhaps been relying too much on federal efforts to bail us out of the assisted suicide mess. With the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in Gonzales vs. Oregon, that is not going to happen.
ARCHBISHOP’S REPORT
Chrism Mass & Holy Week
Priest Assignments
Archbishop’s Appeal
Consistory Pilgrimage
Vocations
Bankruptcy
Upcoming Events
Pastoral Priorities Implementation Update
ARCHDIOCESAN PASTORAL ASSEMBLY
The meeting concluded with a prayer led by B.J. Finleybranch.
NEXT MEETING: Saturday, September
30, 2006
from 10am to 3pm
at TBA
This letter was printed on Archdiocesan letterhead. Office of the Archbishop
April 21, 2006
Dear Friends in Christ,
The first Letter of Peter encourages us to “be ready always to give a reason for the hope that is in you." (1 Peter 3:15) As the Catholic community in Western Oregon gathered to celebrate the Easter mysteries, we discovered anew the reason for the hope and the faith that I see in the faithful of this Archdiocese. Despite ongoing litigation and uncertainty, people continue to be led to the Church; young men are being educated for the priesthood; the Gospel is being preached; the sacraments are being celebrated; our children are being educated; and, the vulnerable are being assisted. This is the reality that provides a larger context for the information I want to share with you at this time.
When I last wrote to you in early January, the Bankruptcy Court had just issued significant rulings. Much has happened since then and I want to keep you up to date on where we are in the Chapter 11 proceedings.
Property litigation. The Archdiocese has appealed the Bankruptcy Court’s December rulings; the parishes, parishioners and schools have also appealed. The appeal will be briefed, and argued sometime this fall. You may recall that the court ruled that parishes have no separate legal existence – that they are merely part of the Archdiocese – and thus parish real estate belongs to the Archdiocese. The court also ruled (using nine parishes and one high school as test properties) that, under bankruptcy law, the interests of those parishes/school in their real property could be eliminated and that those properties are potentially available to pay creditors of the Archdiocese.
The court did not rule that any specific assets are available to pay claims; only that certain real property is potentially available. Issues of charitable trust, donor intent and other restrictions on the use of parish and school property remain to be determined. The court later suggested in another ruling that no parish or school property would be considered available to pay claims until after all relevant issues have been decided and appeals finally resolved.
Another motion is pending to determine whether the Perpetual Endowment Fund, a charitable trust established in 1981 by Archbishop Cornelius Power, is an asset of the Archdiocese available to pay claims. The Archdiocese contends that it is not; that its use is otherwise restricted by the Declaration of Trust establishing the fund. The court will rule on this issue within the next few months.
Mediation of the property case.
Even while the appeal on property rulings and other matters are pending,
we continue to mediate the property case to try to reach a settlement acceptable
to all concerned. The Archdiocese is working closely and cooperatively
with representatives of the parishes and parishioners to achieve a feasible
resolution of the property litigation. The support of parishes and parishioners
will be critical in these efforts.
Tort claims. To complete a plan of reorganization and close the Chapter 11 case, the Archdiocese has requested the court to estimate the value of pending unresolved claims. This will allow us to proceed more expeditiously towards confirmation of our plan of reorganization. The methodology for estimating claims will be determined by the court within the next month or so.
Insurance litigation. The Archdiocese also remains heavily involved in litigation with insurance companies. We have produced hundreds of thousands of documents to insurers and many depositions have been taken. Presently, we are negotiating with several insurance companies and hope to reach settlements with them in the near future.
Plan of reorganization. The Archdiocese filed its plan of reorganization in November 2005. After reviewing objections to this plan, we modified it to address the concerns expressed. The Tort Claimants Committee also filed a plan which it is modifying. The Archdiocese objected to this plan as totally lacking in feasibility in that it intended to use assets to pay claims (including parish and school property) that the court had not yet determined were property of the estate. Both plans will come before the court again next month. In the meantime, the Finance Council and the College of Consultors are considering issues related to funding our plan of reorganization.
Budget cuts. Regardless of what may happen in the bankruptcy case in the coming weeks, we face serious cash flow problems. We will need to cut approximately $1 million in services to the parishes and schools from the Archdiocesan Pastoral Center for the 2006-2007 fiscal year beginning on July 1, 2006. I am concerned about the effect of these cuts, not only on those whose jobs will be affected, but also on all those who depend on services and programs that may no longer be available. No decisions have yet been made as to how the cost savings will be accomplished. I will be meeting with the Presbyteral Council and College of Consultors to hear their thoughts and priorities for services that should continue to be provided by the Pastoral Center and those that we may need to forego and rely on the parishes to provide.
Through all of these challenges, I am encouraged by your faith and your support and the graces our loving Lord continues to shower on us. I count on your prayers and support. Only your generosity will allow us to continue many of the ministries of the Church of Western Oregon.
Sincerely yours in Christ,
(Signed: +John G. Vlazny)
Most Rev. John G. Vlazny
Archbishop of Portland in Oregon
FAITH FORMATION AT ALL
LEVELS
Pastoral Priority Number One
Pastoral Plan:
I. FAITH FORMATION AT ALL LEVELS
• Eucharist-centered
• Personal Encounter with Christ
Catholics of all age groups are hungry for their faith. They are
seeking a deeper relationship with God and a better understanding of their
Catholic faith. It is the aim of the Church to help foster and fulfill
these desires and to walk with all baptized believers on the path to holiness.
By its very nature, faith formation involves
the whole person. Learning about the Catholic faith without having
experienced the love of God cannot constitute true faith formation.
Likewise, an experience of God’s love without a corresponding knowledge
of Jesus Christ and his Church is incomplete. Faith formation engages
both the head and the heart. Growing intellectual knowledge of the
faith coupled with a deepening experiential knowing of the person of Jesus
Christ comprise a genuine faith formation.
The Eucharist is the “source and summit” of our faith. Faith formation
should therefore be centered on the Eucharist. Ways must be found
to lead adults, youth, and children consistently and creatively to an ever
deeper personal encounter with Christ in the Eucharist. It is not
enough to live our faith one hour per week on a Sunday. We are called
to be a holy people. It is the grace of the Eucharist that empowers
us to live the faith in our daily lives.
APC Implementation Strategies:
Faith Formation at All Levels
1. Focus on the Sunday Eucharist as the primary means of faith formation at all levels. Encourage “teaching homilies” on specific Sundays (e.g. teach about the Eucharist on the feast of Corpus Christi, or about the sacrament of reconciliation on a Sunday in Lent). Provide resources for and encourage pastors to explain certain parts of the Mass during the liturgy or to offer “teaching Masses” that help the faithful better understand the celebration.
2. Provide resources for and encourage parishes to form or continue small faith-sharing groups (similar to Disciples in Mission groups) that are centered on the Eucharist.
3. Encourage and assist parishes in the promotion of spending personal time with Jesus in adoration of the Blessed Sacrament outside of Mass. Provide such opportunities at the parish & vicariate level. Encourage the establishment of perpetual adoration chapels where possible.
4. Provide resources for and encourage parishes to offer retreats that
are centered on encountering Christ. Identify priests, deacons and
lay people who are qualified to lead retreats (e.g. Fr. Chun). Provide
a list of retreat centers; include inexpensive options.
Cabinet Recommendations:
At their annual retreat in September of 2005, cabinet members were asked by Archbishop Vlazny to reflect upon and discuss the Pastoral Priority Implementation Strategies developed by the Archdiocesan Pastoral Council. The cabinet members made some recommendations to the bishop about how the strategies could be implemented.
1. Sr. Jeremy Gallet will be asked to form a committee including a priest
and others to look at the strategy of using teaching homilies on specific
Sundays.
2. Tom Gornick will look into materials that might be used for small faith
sharing groups each Lent.
3. The archbishop will encourage adoration prayer before the Blessed Sacrament
in parishes.
4. Todd Cooper will be asked to put together a list of resources for retreats
both within parishes and at retreat centers.
********************************
YOUTH & YOUNG ADULT
MINISTRY
Pastoral Priority Number Two
Pastoral Plan:
II. YOUTH & YOUNG ADULT MINISTRY
• Help young adults
develop a mature faith
• Recruit, train, and
pay qualified coordinators of youth ministry
• Help youth remain
connected to Church as they transition to young adulthood
Youth and young adults together represent the largest single age grouping of Catholics. The Church has a special concern for these younger generations. Youth and young adults deserve the opportunity to experience a vibrant and meaningful faith so that their lives are rich and full of hope. When youth catch on fire with their faith, they provide a profound energy and inspiring presence that is a leaven for the entire community. When young adults become actively involved in parish ministries, they become building blocks for the future of the Church.
One of the primary goals of youth ministry is to create and maintain strong ties between young people and the Church, providing a firm foundation to which they can return and upon which they can rely during the challenging years leading to adulthood. Popular culture often presents, as values, attitudes and behaviors that run contrary to Gospel living. Catholic youth and young adults need support from friends and from the Church in order to live their lives as Christ is calling them to live it – as faithful followers of the Gospel.
Youth and young adult ministry is seen as a major component of faith formation
at all levels. One of the fruits of successful youth and young adult ministry
will be an increase of vocations. With help from their families and
guided by the wisdom of the Church, youth and young adults will grow strong
in their faith and become a sure source of hope for all.
APC Implementation Strategies:
Youth & Young Adult Ministry
1. Promote and support Theology on Tap as a faith formation program for
young adults. Add leadership training and weekend retreats that integrate
peace and justice work with faith formation.
2. Promote Life Teen as an option for parish youth ministry programs where
adequate resources exist.
3. Promote fun faith programs like the Leap of Faith ropes course to bring
youth together.
4. Investigate the recruitment of Religious men & women as resources
for YYA ministry.
5. Create a one-year YYA awareness campaign outlining “The Risk of our
Catholic Youth at the Crossroads.” Encourage parental involvement
in faith formation of their children.
6. Research possibility of long term endowment to fund salaried Youth Training
Director assigned to geographical areas of highest priority.
7. Establish parish visitation & training program through the YYA Ministry
Office in 2006.
8. Add reporting of YYA ministry parish metrics to Archdiocesan Annual
Report.
9. Add a faith formation element to CYO sports events.
Cabinet Recommendations:
1 – 5. The Youth & Young Adult Ministry staff has already begun
to implement the first five
strategies. The office will be asked
to make sure this continues.
6. This recommendation will be reviewed once the archdiocese emerges from
bankruptcy.
7. Youth ministry staff will be encouraged to continue visiting parishes,
especially those where there are no youth ministers. The aim is to
encourage parishes to work cooperatively to provide youth ministry.
8. Fr. Pat Brennan and Mary Jo Tully will work to develop a parish profile
form that could be used every two years to report on the pastoral initiatives,
including youth ministry. This will serve as a tool to measure how
parishes are responding to this priority.
9. The archbishop will contact CYO to see about strengthening faith formation
elements at CYO sports events.
******************************
MULTICULTURAL MINISTRY
Pastoral Priority Number Three
III. MULTI-CULTURAL MINISTRY
• What we can become
together
• Develop multi-cultural
leadership
The APC and Archbishop Vlazny recognize that the face of the Catholic community in western Oregon has been changing rapidly with the addition of people from many different cultures – particularly the Spanish speaking cultures. As a result, we face an important and timely opportunity, not only to meet pastoral needs, but especially to embrace the diverse gifts and spiritual heritages brought to us by peoples of different languages, cultures and regions.
As a community of believers, we must develop a vision of what we can become together. Surely, we will become a greater reflection of God’s love in the world if we share our gifts and our lives with one another. Rather than viewing each other as strangers, we wish to see each other as friends and companions on the journey of faith. In order to achieve this goal, we must learn about each other, spend time together, pray and worship together, take meals, celebrate, work, and live out our one Catholic faith together. We must share our art, our customs, our music, our food, and our devotions for the mutual enrichment of one another. As well, we must share our hearts, our dreams, our talents, and even our brokenness with one another.
Multi-cultural ministry is a vital part of the future of the Church. Only through cooperation and genuine, concerted effort amongst the many cultural groups within the archdiocese can we meet and minister to the spiritual needs of the Church as a whole. Reaching out to each other will sometimes be a difficult challenge, but just imagine what we can become together!
APC Implementation Strategies:
Multicultural Ministry
1. Hold a conference or symposium to define the vision of multicultural
ministry in the archdiocese. Gather representatives from the different
ethnic groups and consultative bodies in the diocese and invite a qualified
speaker to facilitate the process.
2. Establish a website that will serve as a multicultural resource, especially
for pastoral ministers. Include info on each ethnic group and its
respective feast days, devotions, traditions, images and history.
Include links to other resource sites. Designate someone to monitor
and update the site. Site should be offered in different languages.
A committee should be formed to help develop the site and determine what
info should be included.
3. The Pastoral Center should be a model of multicultural ministry.
Priority should be given to hiring bi-lingual employees at the archdiocese,
especially in pastoral ministry positions.
4. Provide language opportunities for English and non-English speakers.
Offer language classes for pastoral ministers where they serve. Encourage
lay parishioners to teach English as a second language (ESL) at parishes.
5. Identify, encourage and seek the help of the leaders in different cultural
groups within parishes.
6. Through the Justice & Peace Office and Catholic Charities, create
awareness in our faith communities of the plight of fellow Catholics who
are immigrants and are impoverished. Arrange forums where people
can share their stories. Supply info on current legislation
and its impact on people.
Cabinet Recommendations:
1. The cabinet will
look toward the idea of holding a conference or symposium about multicultural
ministry in the near future
2. Todd Cooper and
Bud Bunce will be asked to work on the website that could serve as a multicultural
resource for pastors and pastoral ministers.
3. The Pastoral Center
will continue looking for employees from diverse cultural backgrounds
4. Raul Velazquez and
Leda Saenz will be asked to look into opportunities for both Spanish and
English language study
5. In identifying multicultural
leaders, focus should be on Hispanics, Vietnamese, African Americans, Koreans,
Filipinos, Italians and Eastern Europeans
6. The Justice and
Peace Office and Catholic Charities can assist parishes in becoming more
aware of the plight of the poor. St. Andrew’s Parish could also serve
as a resource in sharing how it has implemented this priority. Parish
twinning should be seriously considered where parishes with many resources
could share with a poorer partner.
***************************************